What We Recommend for Every New Pet Parent (Natural Nutrition Guide 2025)

Posted on 24 July 2025
By Dr. Jill Tack, Board Certified Naturopathic Doctor
Posted in Cat Feeding, Dog Feeding, Pet Feeding
0

Learn what The Pet Beastro recommends for new pet parents. Discover goat milk, probiotics, fresh food toppers, and treats to support your puppy or kitten’s health.

Bringing home a new puppy or kitten? Congratulations! Whether you’re a first-time pet parent or getting back into the rhythm, one of the most common questions we hear at The Pet Beastro is:

“What products should I start with?”

We’re so glad you asked, because starting your pet off with the right nutrition and support makes a big difference in their long-term health and happiness. Even small upgrades go a long way, especially when you’re focused on building a strong gut, a calm mind, and a resilient immune system.

Here’s our expert-approved list of must-have products and habits for new pet parents, rooted in natural wellness, real food, and everything we love at The Pet Beastro.

1. Goat Milk: Gentle Support for Digestion and Immunity

Why we recommend it:
Goat milk is one of the closest alternatives to mother’s milk. It’s packed with enzymes, probiotics, and nutrients that are easy to absorbmaking it ideal for puppies, kittens, and sensitive tummies.

Benefits of goat milk for dogs and cats:

Supports digestion and gut health
Hydrating and nutrient-dense
Natural source of probiotics and enzymes
Helps ease the transition to a new home or food
Ideal for bedtime or post-meal calm

What to try:

Green Juju Goat Milk – Simple, clean, and powerful
Solutions Pet Products Sheep’s Milk – Nutritionally similar to mother’s milk (arriving soon)

2. Single-Ingredient Training Treats: Clean and Effective

Why we recommend them:
Early training is essential, and treats should be both rewarding and healthy. Single-ingredient treats are freeze-dried, species-appropriate, and packed with flavor.

Best choices for training:

Vital Essentials Freeze-Dried Treats
Shepherd Boy Farms Single-Ingredient Treats

Look for:

One simple ingredient (beef, duck, turkey, etc.)
No additives, fillers, or preservatives
Easy to break into small training pieces

3. Fresh Food, Even as a Topper

Why we recommend it:
You don’t have to go fully raw to see benefits. Even just adding 10% fresh food can improve digestion, immunity, and overall wellness.

Start with:

Raw or gently cooked food toppers
Goat milk, bone broth, or raw eggs
Fresh produce blends (like Green Juju)

Benefits of fresh food for pets:

More bioavailable nutrients
Fewer fillers = better digestion
Healthier skin, coat, and energy

4. Rotational Feeding: Variety Builds Resilience

Why we recommend it:
Feeding different proteins, textures, and formulas trains your pet’s digestive system to adaptreducing picky eating and strengthening gut diversity.

Tips for rotational feeding:

Switch protein sources every few weeks
Alternate between raw, freeze-dried, or gently cooked
Use different brands to expose your pet to a variety

5. Use Interactive Toys or Slow Feeders

Why we recommend it:
Feeding your pet from an interactive toy adds mental stimulation, encourages natural foraging behavior, and slows down fast eaters.

Best for:

Boredom busting
Mealtime enrichment
Reducing anxiety during crate time

Ideas:

Stuff with goat milk-soaked treats
Mix raw food with freeze-dried toppers
Use treat balls or lick mats

6. Probiotics and Digestive Enzymes: The Secret to a Healthy Gut

Why we recommend them:
New environments, new foods, and stress can lead to digestive upset. Adding probiotics and enzymes helps balance the microbiome and reduce stool issues, especially during transition periods.

Our favorite for puppies and kittens:

Adored Beast Love Bugs Probiotic Blend
A species-specific formula with no fillersjust gut-supporting goodness.

Also consider:

Digestive enzyme blends with papaya or bromelain
Raw goat milk or kefir for natural enzyme support

7. Do a Quick Food Audit: Time for an Upgrade?

What to check:

Look for ingredients like corn, wheat, soy, or meat by-products
Check for artificial colors, preservatives, or unnamed proteins
Aim for named proteins (like turkey, lamb, or rabbit), limited ingredients, and natural sources

If your current food contains low-quality ingredients, it’s time to upgrade. We’re happy to help you find a better option that fits your budget and feeding style.

Need Help Getting Started?

Whether your new pet is tiny, nervous, excited, or unsurenutrition makes a difference. At The Pet Beastro in Madison Heights and Warren, Michigan, we specialize in holistic, species-appropriate solutions to help pets thrive from day one.

Come visit our team in-store or shop online to find the products we trust for new puppies and kittensbecause feeding better today means fewer vet visits tomorrow.